Thursday, December 30, 2010

The Story Behind the Star-Spangled Banner (Except Not Really)

With snow piling up in Colorado it looks like I have some extra time to devote to blogging this weekend. To start things off, I wanted to address a video that has become quite popular over the past few months. In fact, three different people have sent it to me via email this past week. The video is of a man named Dudley Rutherford. Rutherford is the Pastor of the Shepherd of the Hills Church in California. In the video, Rutherford gives a stirring and patriotic account of what he calls the story behind the National Anthem. The video has gained so much attention that even Glenn Beck, pseudo historian extraordiaire, is planning on having Mr. Rutherford on to discuss the "real" history of our nation's anthem. Take a look:



Now, before I point out where he went terribly wrong with his history let me first state for the record that I admire Mr. Rutherford's love of country. One of the things I appreciate most about the Christian right is their reverence for this nation and their appreciation for those who went before us. In my opinion, this is something that the secularists on the left (and yes, I realize that not every secularist fits this mold) either detests or can't seem to understand. With that said, I do want to address Mr. Rutherford's woefully inaccurate account in the video above. I do so with the intent to simply correct the history. In no way am I suggesting that Mr. Rutherford is a diabolical liar bent on twisting history for his own personal gain.

1.) About 39 seconds in, Rutherford stated that "the colonies were engaged in vicious conflict with the mother country, Britain." Rutherford continuously refers to "the colonies" throughout the video, which reveals very poor chronology on his part. The American Revolution lasted from 1775 to 1783, and the U.S. Constitution was adopted in 1787, which means that "the colonies" had become a thing of the past. By the time Francis Scott Key met with the British at the Battle of Baltimore the United States had been a sovereign nation for over 30 years. They were not "colonies". Rutherford messes up his chronology by assuming that the Battle of Baltimore took place during the American Revolution, and he is incorrect.

2.) Key did not sail out to the British to free a bunch of prisoners. In fact, he sailed out in order to free only ONE prisoner, Dr. William Beanes. As for Rutherford's claim that Key tried to liberate a bunch of men who were being kept in chains in a cargo hold, this is completely not true. In reality, Key was considered a "guest" on board a British command frigate, where he dined with other British "gentleman." From the Library of Congress website:
When the British invaded Washington in 1814, Ross and Cockburn with their staff officers made their headquarters in Upper Marlboro, Md., at the residence of a planter, Dr. William Beanes, whom they subsequently seized as a prisoner. Upon hearing of his friend's capture, Key resolved to release him, and was aided by President Madison, who ordered that a vessel that had been used as a cartel should be placed at his service, and that John S. Skinner, agent for the exchange of prisoners, should accompany him. Gen. Ross finally consented to Dr. Beanes's release, but said that the party must be detained during the attack on Baltimore.

Key and Skinner were transferred to the frigate "Surprise," commanded by the admiral's son, Sir Thomas Cockburn, and soon afterward returned under guard of British sailors to their own vessel, whence they witnessed the engagement.
Again, no account of hundreds of men, in chains, in a dark cargo hold being comforted by Francis Scott Key.

3.) Rutherford continuously refers to the fort as "Fort Henry." It was actually called Fort McHenry.

4.) Rutherford is right when he states that Key, Beanes, and John Skinner (who accompanied Key) were not allowed to return to shore, due to the impending attack by the British. This point, however, is about the only point Rutherford gets right. He then completely derails and really screws up the true history. Rutherford claims that Admiral Alexander Cochrane, who was in command of the British naval forces, informed Key that he was going to reduce Fort McHenry to rubble. This isn't true. The British had no intention of destroying the fort but instead wanted to capture it.

5.) Rutherford states that Admiral Cochrane informed Francis Scott Key that "the entire British war fleet...with hundreds of ships" were going to attack the "Fort Henry." This is completely untrue. The British only had 19 ships at Baltimore, nothing more. In addition, only 8 or 9 of those ships actually fired on the fort, since the other ships didn't have the guns that could reach the shore. Also, it is important to note that Cochrane had sent a landing party of British soldiers to attempt to gain intelligence. Cochrane then ordered his ships to pull back and only attack the redoubts of the fort. He clearly didn't want to destroy the fort or inadvertently kill his own men who he had sent ashore.

6.) There were no women or children in the fort. Another bogus claim. I think Rutherford states this because there was one woman killed in the bombardment. She was trying to bring her husband and other men dinner when a bomb took her out.

7.) Rutherford is 100% wrong when he states than men from the fort held the flag up "until they died" and that "the patriot's bodies" were piled around the flag pole. Not true. Only 3-5 soldiers were killed in the fort, nothing more.

*** On a side note, I am curious to know if the Washington quote that Rutherford brings up is true. He claims that Key was inspired by Washington's following words:
"The thing that separates the American Christian from every other person on earth is the fact that he would rather die on his feet, than live on his knees!"
I have looked around and cannot find anything to substantiate or repudiate that Washington did/did not say this. Anyone out there have the answer?

In conclusion, my intention is not to make fun of Mr. Rutherford or to start calling him a pathological liar. Instead, I simply believe that patriotism based on mythical history really isn't patriotism, and sadly, too many people gobble this stuff up as gospel. After all, it came from a pastor!

***Update: In the post I mistakenly stated that Mr. Rutherford was going to be on Glenn Beck's show. That is not true. Rutherford informed me that he has never been in contact with Mr. Beck and has no plans to be on his program. My apologies for the error.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks for this. I also received this video from a friend, and was struck by what seemed to be inaccuracies in the story. My problem is not with the patriotism that obviously motivated the story, but that the true story is a great one that does not need embellishment. And to make up stuff implies otherwise. Wasn't there also a sudden storm that wreaked havoc on the British fleet during the bombardment?
Thanks.

Brian Tubbs said...

Brad, I've heard several parts of this mythical embellishment before. It's been circulating for quite some time. I'm glad Pastor Rutherford read your corrections and publicly acknowledged the errors. It speaks highly of him.

Steve MC said...

Thanks for not only correcting this story, but for a level-headed view of it and the Pastor's intentions.

Love for country is great, but too often it means accepting what you hear without checking it out, even in this age of instant information.

KMD said...

Thank goodness I found this. I was about to show it to my Webelos den for their Citizenship requirement. I too noticed some inaccuracies (colonies and Fort Henry and it not being a military base.) but I thought the story would hold their attention. Going to start my search again!! Thanks
KMD
Webelos Den leader

drumchik said...

I just became familiar with this video today as it circulating Facebook (again?) in celebration of Independence Day. The George Washington "quote" that you also questioned was the first thing that jumped out as contrived so that's where I started my own research. (I found your nicely organized summary much later.) According to the folks at Mt. Vernon, who are indisputably the experts on all things Washington, "There is no known quote from Washington in any of his writings or papers that reflected this sentiment." This is stated on their page of accumulated spurious quotations. http://www.mountvernon.org/digital-encyclopedia/article/spurious-quotations/

The rest of my research resulted in identifying the same inaccuracies that you outline here. Another interesting summary of the true story can be found on Smithsonian.com's website: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-story-behind-the-star-spangled-banner-149220970/?no-ist

Thanks for your efforts in setting the record straight. I too believe that "patriotism based on mythical history really isn't patriotism." Well said, and well done.

Anonymous said...

The quote comes from José Marti a Cuban freedom fighter n in the 1890s and was popularized by EMILIANO ZAPATA in Mexico in 1910. (it wasn't talking about "American Christians").

evaair said...


I can not see your video

Unknown said...

شركة تسليك مجاري بالدمام
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالجبيل
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة المثالى تيوب
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالجبيل
شركة تنظيف فلل بالدمام
شركة تنظيف شقق بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة مكافحة الحشرات بالدمام
شركة تسليك مجارى بالجبيل

Blogger said...

Are you paying more than $5 for each pack of cigarettes? I buy high quality cigarettes from Duty Free Depot and I save over 70%.

afaf elgamal said...

شركة عزل أسطح بأبها
شركة عزل حمامات بأبها
شركة عزل خزانات بمحايل


شركة عزل حمامات بخميس مشيط
شركة عزل اسطح بخميس مشيط
شركة عزل اسطح وحمامات بمحايل
شركة كشف تسربات بخميس مشيط
شركة كشف تسربات مياة بأبها

Unknown said...


شركة تنظيف فلل بأبها
شركة تنظيف شقق بابها


شركة تنظيف منازل بأبها
شركة تنظيف مجالس بابها
شركة ننظيف موكيت بأبها
شركة تنظيف خزانات بأبها
شركةتنظيف منازل بخميس مشيط
شركة تنظيف فلل بخميس مشيط
شركة تنظيف شقق بخميس مشيط

Unknown said...

شركة عزل اسطح بجازان
شركة عزل اسطح وحمامات بنجران
شركة رش مبيد بجازان
شركة كشف تسربات بنجران
شركة مكافحة نمل ابيض بنجران
شركة كشف تسربات بجازان
شركة عزل خزانات بجازان
شركة مكافحة حشرات بنجران


شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بجازان
شركة تنظيف خزانات بجازان

Unknown said...

DO YOU NEED A LOAN : TRUST ME WE CAN SOLVE YOUR FINANCE PROBLEM
Do you need Personal Loan?
Business Cash Loan?
Unsecured Loan
Fast and Simple Loan?
Quick Application Process?
Approvals within 24-72 Hours?
No Hidden Fees Loan?
Funding in less than 1 Week?
Get unsecured working capital?
Contact Us At : royalworldfundings@gmail.com
Phone number :+1-724-9771-197 (Whatsapp Only)

LOAN SERVICES AVAILABLE INCLUDE:

Commercial Loans.
Personal Loans.
Business Loans.
Investments Loans.
Development Loans.
Acquisition Loans .
Construction loans.
Credit Card Clearance Loan
Debt Consolidation Loan
Business Loans And many More Loan Opportunity:

LOAN APPLICATION FORM:
=================
Full Name:................
Loan Amount Needed:.
Purpose of loan:.......
Loan Duration:..
Gender:.............
Marital status:....
Location:..........
Home Address:..
City:............
Country:......
Phone:..........
Mobile / Cell:....
Occupation:......
Monthly Income:....

Contact Us At royalworldfundings@gmail.com
Phone number :+1-724-9771-197 (Whatsapp Only)

FAST LOAN OFFER whats-App +918929509036 said...

We Offer Loan At A Very Low Rate Of 3%. If Interested, Kindly Contact Us. email us at (fastloanoffer34@gmail.com) /whats-App Contact Number +918929509036

URGENT LOAN OFFER WHATSAPP +918929509036 said...

Do not use all of these Private Money Lender here.They are located in Nigeria, Ghana Turkey, France and Israel.My name is Mrs.Emily Michael, I am from Canada. Have you been looking for a loan?Do you need an urgent personal or business loan?contact Fast Legitimate Loan Approval he help me with a loan of $95,000 some days ago after been scammed of $12,000 from a woman claiming to be a loan lender from Nigeria but i thank God today that i got my loan worth $95,000.Feel free to contact the company for a genuine financial contact Email:(creditloan11@gmail.com)

INVEST WITH $200 AND GET A RETURNS OF $2,000 said...

Invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days.
Why wasting your precious time online looking for a loan? When there is an opportunity for you to invest with 200$ and get a returns of 5,000$ within seven business working days. Contact us now for more information if interested on how you can earn big with just little amount. This is all about investing into Crude Oil and Gas Business.

Email: investmoneyoilgas@gmail.com

UNITED GLOBAL FINANCIER said...

WE SPECIALIZE IN FAST APPROVALS
You can access our Credit/funding facilities from Any location in the world.
Reply for more information about our credit offer via Email: unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com


Are you frustrated or tired of seeking Financial assistance from Bank and different financial organization, have you encountered company with unsatisfied financial services?
Here is your chance to secure fast and genuine money lending at a very low interest rate. For more information,
Email: unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com


We offer the right solution to your financial needs.We stand apart from other lenders because we believe in customer service, and we stay with you until you get the results you want.In general we offer home finances,car finances,commercial finances,business finances,e.t.c, at lower interest rate of 3%.
We provide our prospective customer long lasting financial solutions that helps their companies thrive and grow"and also help them to invest and clear you existing debts. Email: unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com
Contact us now for more information.


We are financial builders and we give out loan to everyone ranging from personal, commercial, business financial with our amounts ranging from min 2,000.00 to 1,000,000.00 with a fixed and very low interest rate of 3%. Do you want to own a company? Do you want to own a Home? Is Your Company having financial problem? Do you have a contract/project and need money to fund it? Apply for a financial today and get financed within 3-4 working
days.Email: unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com

Do you need a Loan?
Are you looking for Finance?
Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
I think you have come to the right place.
We offer Loans atlow interest rate.
Interested people should please contact us on
For immediate response to your application, Kindly
reply to this email: unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com

DO YOU NEED A LOAN : TRUST ME WE CAN SOLVE YOUR FINANCE PROBLEM
Do you need Personal Loan?
Business Cash Loan?
Unsecured Loan
Fast and Simple Loan?
Quick Application Process?
Approvals within 24-72 Hours?
No Hidden Fees Loan?
Funding in less than 1 Week?
Get unsecured working capital?
Contact Us At : unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com

LOAN SERVICES AVAILABLE INCLUDE:
================================
*Commercial Loans.
*Personal Loans.
*Business Loans.
*Investments Loans.
*Development Loans.
*Acquisition Loans .
*Construction loans.
*Credit Card Clearance Loan
*Debt Consolidation Loan
*Business Loans And many More:

LOAN APPLICATION FORM:
=================
Full Name:................
Loan Amount Needed:.
Purpose of loan:.......
Loan Duration:..
Gender:.............
Marital status:....
Location:..........
Home Address:..
City:............
Country:......
Phone:..........
Mobile / Cell:....
Occupation:......
Monthly Income:....

Contact Us At : unitedglobalfinancier@gmail.com

Anonymous said...

kyrie 7
bape
supreme clothing
Travis Scott Jordan
yeezy 350
cheap jordans
pg shoes
golden goose
adidas yeezy
jordan 12